Hi there,
A very interesting opportunity and quite a generous one too, which ever subject wins in the end; the talent of the artist giving much for for a voter to ponder what they will make of the winning topic

.
Though, I will have to betray a certain bias in this respect

. I have personally swung for the Fey and May continuation. Though I would not wish to critique, I would hope others would realise the almost unique opportunity here to further evolve a fairly original idea, as opposed to other possibilities which may prove more, shall we say, generic or fashionable at the moment

.
To highlight this, some compelling examples of the Fey and May narrative (Foot Fiend and Werewolf resepectively) from the artist: -
"Her Secret" Parts 1-3
http://fav.me/d1glnbc http://fav.me/d1gw45o http://fav.me/d1h2gt4
A "Foot Fiend" TF
http://fav.me/d38d2c7
Still, the contest seems to be doing well and anything could emerge at this fairly early stage

.
Thanks,
Alchemical Night.