The far, FAR away #1 winner for me is
Back to Basics.
I can read that one over and over. The vast majority of 'caption photos' on my computer are ones I made by just posting quotes from that story over photos. I never get tired of them.
2 - Yes,
For a Girl gets #2, and look at that...both of my favorite stories are by the same author!
3 -
Sheena
4 -
Sheryl
Those are the four that instantly come to mind without looking at my folder of stories. I just glanced in there, though, and saw two classics. So here are my runners-up:
The Haunted House by Ed Miller
Bracelet of Love by Stephanie