Kim and the ring (BE, FMG, growth)

pilif83 · 05-20-2010

PyroWildcat · 05-20-2010

Proof that overdone muscle growth can ruin anything.

Vengeance1701 · 05-20-2010

Indeed.

It's like looking at a dude eventually.

someguyontheinterwebnets · 05-20-2010

I liked it.

vidgamer85 · 05-20-2010

Quote:

Originally Posted by PyroWildcat

Proof that overdone muscle growth can ruin anything.

Permit me to strongly disagree with an ignorant statement. It depends on the drawing style of the artist more than anything; certainly not the generalization you seem to believe.

Now while I would say this topic belongs in the growth section far more than here, at the same time I would issue a polite "stow it" to the negative statements. It doesn't have to be positive, but if your commentary isn't going to at least be constructive then do spare us.

Now, as for constructive criticism I'd say the one thing I recommend is to tone down on the hands just a tad. That's the one part that really comes across as a bit too manly. Take my advice as you will, just something to consider down the line.

CK01 · 05-20-2010

Very nice, and certainly unique way for the muscles to grow (admittedly make sense if the its the ring)

Marmalade-Beat · 05-20-2010

Well increase in musculature to me is a more delicate practice than most inflation and expansion processes as it affects the entire build of the subject rather than selectively adding body fat somewhere.
Suspension of disbelief breaks entirely for most if you have uneven mass so joints would snap in two from the pressure or you have ultra cut muscles that don't even exist.

I like the process itself from an artistic standpoint but the end result.....

PyroWildcat · 05-20-2010

Quote:

Originally Posted by vidgamer85

Permit me to strongly disagree with an ignorant statement. It depends on the drawing style of the artist more than anything; certainly not the generalization you seem to believe.

Now while I would say this topic belongs in the growth section far more than here, at the same time I would issue a polite "stow it" to the negative statements.

1. Calling me ignorant just because I don't like what you like isn't exactly polite.

2. For me, style has nothing to do it; I simply think overdone muscles do not look good on anything or anyone, and that includes guys. I'm not normally one to go into topics just to complain about content, but when you throw what is clearly just a GTS/FMG work at me and try to claim that it's BE, you can bet your ass I'm going to say something about it.

Hooded_Miracle · 05-20-2010

Quote:

Originally Posted by PyroWildcat

1. Calling me ignorant just because I don't like what you like isn't exactly polite.

2. For me, style has nothing to do it; I simply think overdone muscles do not look good on anything or anyone, and that includes guys. I'm not normally one to go into topics just to complain about content, but when you throw what is clearly just a GTS/FMG work at me and try to claim that it's BE, you can bet your ass I'm going to say something about it.

He said it was FMG/GTS.

In the title.

That you clicked on.

Also, saying that someone else's fetish is bad while saying that they should have had BE is kind of ignorant and/or hypocritical. >_>

PyroWildcat · 05-20-2010

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hooded_Miracle

Also, saying that someone else's fetish is bad while saying that they should have had BE is kind of ignorant and/or hypocritical. >_>

Pay attention. I didn't say the fetish was bad, I said that I didn't like it, and my problem was that what was pretty much a purely GTS sequence was posted in the BE forum. This belongs in Growth, not here.

Hooded_Miracle · 05-20-2010

Quote:

Originally Posted by PyroWildcat

Proof that overdone muscle growth can ruin anything.

You said it ruined it. Hence, you didn't like it.

If you thought it should have belonged somewhere else, you should have said so first, not about how you dislike it.

Marmalade-Beat · 05-20-2010

If we're going to argue semantics, overdone would generally be muscle proportions or definition beyond the realm of reality even for males.
Liking the fetish or disliking it as a whole has nothing to do with it having artistic limits for the majority.

On the other side, yeah, Pyro could have handled that better.

05-20-2010	#2
PyroWildcat Perverted Skeleton Join Date: May 2006 Posts: 1,041	Re: Kim and the ring (BE, FMG, growth) Proof that overdone muscle growth can ruin anything. __________________ See my BE fiction at the Overflowing Bra. Also see my Hentai-Foundry account here. And my FurAffinity account(probably the best one to get at all of my stories and commissioned pics). The main target of my writing for a fair bit of time - my posts on the BEAddventure

05-20-2010	#3
Vengeance1701 Modest Moderator Join Date: Aug 2006 Posts: 3,998	Re: Kim and the ring (BE, FMG, growth) Indeed. It's like looking at a dude eventually. __________________ Meh. Cranky and old.

05-20-2010	#4
someguyontheinterwebnets Frequent Poster Join Date: Feb 2008 Posts: 119	Re: Kim and the ring (BE, FMG, growth) I liked it.

05-20-2010	#6
CK01 Process Disciple Join Date: May 2005 Location: Australia Posts: 1,165	Re: Kim and the ring (BE, FMG, growth) Very nice, and certainly unique way for the muscles to grow (admittedly make sense if the its the ring) __________________ http://cyckath.deviantart.com/ Cosplay Deviants = Sexy Buy Spinnerette Volume 1 Today!

05-20-2010	#7
Marmalade-Beat Childhood Corruptor Lv.9 Join Date: Mar 2007 Posts: 467	Re: Kim and the ring (BE, FMG, growth) Well increase in musculature to me is a more delicate practice than most inflation and expansion processes as it affects the entire build of the subject rather than selectively adding body fat somewhere. Suspension of disbelief breaks entirely for most if you have uneven mass so joints would snap in two from the pressure or you have ultra cut muscles that don't even exist. I like the process itself from an artistic standpoint but the end result..... Last edited by Marmalade-Beat; 05-20-2010 at 12:41 PM.